Fire Quinito
Follow this blog:
Search Fire Quinito:
Home · About the Blog Name · About the Author · What People Say about Fire Quinito · Email: j@firequinito.com

Rafe Bartholomew calls out Andy Jao’s racist comment

Posted by Jaemark Tordecilla on August 3, 2010 at 15:28 | Comments (18)
Share
Tweet

Most everything that comes out in Rafe’s blog is a must-read (except for the clips of him singing, only his screaming fangirls would enjoy those), but his latest piece, I feel, is particularly important. In it, he calls out PBA analyst “Dr. J” Andy Jao for making a racist comment about Topex Robinson and Jason Castro in an Alaska-Talk N Text playoff game last week.

[Context: Alaska is about to pull away from TNT. LA Tenorio played a great first four and a half minutes of the third quarter, and Tim Cone subs Topex Robinson to give Tenorio a rest.]

Andy Jao: I think also [Tim Cone] wants to match up Topex Robinson against [Jason] Castro. [pause] Same color.

[Two long, awkward seconds pass, while Mico wonders how to respond.]

Mico Halili: [murmurs] OK. ... [recovers a little] ... Partners!

Jao: Parehong malakas tumalon! Parehong mabilis! [Same hops! Same speed!]

Halili: [desperate to change the subject] And here's DeVance!

I was watching the game at the same time, and cringed too after that exchange. I don’t think enough people took offense to it; we were tweeting about the exchange while it happened, and no one among the people who follow me reacted. And these are the same people who react to the most mundane things.

So I’m glad that Rafe is pushing the conversation forward, because honestly, I couldn’t. I think I’m a smart guy, and I guess I’m thoughtful enough to at least appreciate the issue. But I’ve never had to handle something like this head on, and I grew up in a culture where it was ok to laugh at Whitney Tyson just because she’s black. I’m still a work in progress. I just don’t have the breadth of perspective about an issue like this, so there’s always the opportunity to learn.

But Rafe’s one of the few people who have a thoughtful understanding of both American and Filipino cultures, the context that racism can happen in both cultures, and most importantly – working knowledge of how to correct these and move forward:

Topex Robinson and Jason Castro are both half-black basketball players raised in the Philippines. Robinson is from Olongapo, the town that abutted and indeed grew around the U.S. Naval Base at Subic Bay. From what I've seen, Castro is from Sasmuan (officially no longer Sexmoan) and Guagua, neighboring municipalities in Pampanga, the province that was home to the U.S. Clark Air Force Base. Zambales and Pampanga, particularly the areas around Olongapo and Angeles Cities, are known for having large populations of half-American Filipinos. Also, because both cities are home to extensive sex industries and fairly seedy reputations, people are quick to assume -- often incorrectly, but also often correctly -- that half-American Pinoys from these areas come from ignominious unions. Racial attitudes in the Philippines toward African Americans definitely have an ugly side. They're the same ugly stereotypes that exist in America, only amplified and more acceptable when expressed publicly. So people may be even quicker to assume the worst about half-black Filipinos from Zambales and Pampanga.

So there's definitely something menacing and inappropriate about Andy Jao's chortling joke that Topex Robinson and Jason Castro should be matched up because they're the "same color" with the same jumping ability and quickness.

…

Would Jao have said the same thing if Norman Black was on the panel? Sadly, there's a decent chance he would have. Slights like this would be nothing new to Coach Norman, who has endured plenty of them over the years (I remember an ugly column calling him “A black coach named Black”). Still, neither he nor Robinson nor Castro should have to just put up with it as if being the butt of mildly racist jokes is just a fact of life. Attitudes can and do change over time, and while I don't think Jao should be made to do some American-style media perp-walk with a forced apology, I think his employers at Solar can and should remind him that jokes like the “same color” line aren’t cool.
Share
Tweet

Comments (18) | Trackbacks (2)
Tags: Alaska Aces, Basketball, LA Tenorio, Philippine Basketball Association, Philippine sports media, Talk N Text Tropang Texters

Trackbacks

PingBack
Weblog: topsy.com
Tracked: Aug 03, 15:56
PingBack
Weblog: thehotdogstand.net
Tracked: Apr 24, 06:19

Trackback specific URI for this entry


Comments

#1 Jimbo on 2010-08-03 15:43 (Reply)
Yup, overheard this too ..... and cringed a little as well.

Overall, Andy Jao is one of the milder commentators for as long as I remember ...... one of the very few who knows the technical aspects of the game as well.

Should be just a slip-up on AJ's part. A small talk with the boss is in order.

Now if it was someone like that asshole commentator before ..... Chino Trinidad .....
#1.1 Ahole on 2010-08-03 17:46 (Reply)
At least you don't need to listen to someone calling the game with lines like "recycled shot clock" and "handling the spheroid". Now that's a douchebag right there.
#2 The Legendary Skyflakes25 on 2010-08-03 20:08 (Reply)
we're quick to raise howl when we're the subject of racism or any racial slur for that matter. but when one of us is guilty of this, we prefer to shut up and be silent.

in fact, Filipinos are as worst as any race in this regard. At some point we hurl these terms derogatorily: Baluga, Bumbay, Bisaya, Intsik Beho, Sakang, Egoy, etc.

as a society, we really need to grow up.
#2.1 Mysterious Blue Eagle Man on 2010-08-03 21:38 (Reply)
Hey Legendary Skyflakes, check out the discussion under Rafe's post. It's gotten quite interesting. Medyo may kapareho ata sa sinasabi mo .
#2.1.1 The Legendary Skyflakes25 on 2010-08-04 00:31 (Reply)
hahaha we may have the same view on racism in the Philippines.
#3 Alas on 2010-08-04 07:29 (Reply)
Take it as it is "same color" Anything wrong? same height, same width, same color, same race.
#4 kb8 on 2010-08-04 17:13 (Reply)
rafe is applying american sensitivity to our culture. the thing is, americans have a sense of guilt when it comes to race, while we don't. sure, we call them names like bumbays, chengwa, etc, but in our history, we've never really done anything horrible to other races. in fact, those with chinese and indian bloods have gotten way ahead in our society. we haven't burned down chinese/indian/(insert race here), lynched anyone, nor discriminate to such a point that they would be disadvantaged. that's probably why "racism" (in the sense of name-calling) is accepted here in our country...because wala tayong ina-agrabiyado.

americans, on the other hand, have a history and even a culture of discrimination and disadvantaging other races. that's why rafe is so sensitive about it. but rafe, this is the philippines. we're not a-holes to other people like americans are. we don't have a superiority complex that you guys are afflicted with. so quit applying your sensitivities, belief and guilt to the culture of other countries.
#4.1 jaemark on 2010-08-04 17:16 (Reply)
"we're not a-holes to other people like americans are."

Actually, in this case, you are being an asshole.
#5 kb8 on 2010-08-04 17:48 (Reply)
yep, that didn't come out right. my mistake for the sweeping generalization of americans (caucasians in particular), as im sure that a lot more of them are against racism, even though having stayed there for a significant amount of time, their fear of and problems with race relations still do exist.

my apologies. i do stand by my other opinions though.
#6 commentor on 2010-08-05 02:55 (Reply)
1 word, disgusting!

I do believe that filipinos are 1 of the most racist in the world. wala lang tayong na-agrabyado, simply because we cant. we dont have the money and resources to do so. if we were a rich nation, we'll do so much worse than name calling.
#6.1 The Legendary Skyflakes25 on 2010-08-05 03:17 (Reply)
if the white Americans have grabbed the lands of the Native Americans / American Indians, so are the Filipino lowlanders who have managed to throw highlanders / natives / indigenous people out of their ancestral domains.
#6.2 kb8 on 2010-08-05 09:17 (Reply)
"wala lang tayong na-agrabyado, simply because we cant. we dont have the money and resources to do so."

my point exactly, we have never acted or done anything violent to express our racism, unlike what happened in the united states or other countries. regardless if it were because we were not rich or what, the thing is, we didn't do anything worse than name-calling. that's why we need not apply american- or european-sensitivity to the issue. we do not have the guilt of institutional and violent racism like what happened to native americans, african-americans or jews.
#7 kb8 on 2010-08-05 09:03 (Reply)
before the 70s, we were the second most-advanced nation in asia. we called the chinese as beho, etc, but it never denigrated to anything worse than that. we were relatively rich then, we could have been violent in our racism as what some indonesians did to their chinese-blooded countrymen, but we didn't do any worse than name-calling.

re lowlanders throwing highlanders/natives out of their domains....aside from marcos's attempt to drive the kalingas out, our indigenous people still have their own land (ok, aside from the aetas as well, but pinatubo had something to do with that, not lowlanders). and we cant even really use the kalingas as a real example because most of the things done during the dictatorship was abhorrent, despicable and out of the ordinary.

i digress too much. anyway, i respect your opinions, but back to basketball-related programming...
#7.1 jim minmay on 2010-08-05 13:48 (Reply)
kb8, your comments lead me to believe that you think that Filipinos are racist, but it's alright since we haven't killed any Jews and we're not assholes like white people are. To top it all off, you'e not at all wary of just how much a state of mind like yours could foster passive institutionalized racism. After all, the way you think affects the way you act. You just might be the Filipino Hitler bro
#8 kb8 on 2010-08-06 11:35 (Reply)
no, it's not alright to be racist. what im saying is that we need not apply american- or european-(over)sensitivity to the issue. we're a relatively-gentle people, and except for the actions of the marcos dictatorship, we have never resorted to wholesale killings. i dont even think we have had killings just because of someone's race (again, outside the ones done during the despot's rule).

re assholes like white people, kindly take all my above posts as a whole. ive already apologized for the sweeping generalization, which i did while trying to make a point.

not sure what you mean by passive institutionalized racism. for me kasi (and i may be wrong), anything institutionalized must be done actively, whether thru laws, statutes or policies.

but yes, filipinos are generally racist. we all, or we know someone who, have called or viewed indians as indian panas and money-lenders who are guilty of usury, chinese as chekwas who will put one over you in business dealings, and anyone with dark skin as negro. but we do it in the same vein that we view our own as flat-nosed and always lazy and late. pinoy eh. so again, it doesn't denigrate into anything worse than name-calling.
#9 Jude Turcuato on 2010-08-09 18:05 (Reply)
I agree that there was racism in that comment and although I didn't hear it myself, it probably wasn't as offensive when it was said because the attributes was generally more positive than negative.

Peace.
#10 rehaz on 2010-08-15 16:16 (Reply)
for me, i see no racism in Dr. J's comments. So it's like what kb8 us saying, it can be considered name calling. And yes, the comments are borderline discriminating, but still not racist. For filipinos, we see the color of the skin as what it is, color, and not race. And Dr. J's comments are still a little off and shouldn't have been said.
As for Filipinos being racist, its true. But everyone is just about as racist as you. Sorry, can't help singing that song from Avenue Q. And as the title suggest "Everyone's A Little Bit Racist." so relax. :D
#11 duders on 2010-08-19 16:57 (Reply)
Some people always try to be 'politically correct' because they think it go hand in hand with being smart...

"same color" what the hell is wrong with that phrase? as Kb says, we see things in different perspective as the Americans. The Americans are hypocrite by being so sensitive about these things because they are the one who created the "slavery" of African people in their home soil. So the mere mention of "color", "black" and "N" they act like they do not allow it because of their guilt feelings of their past.

We are not Americans, just because someone from Ophrah complained about racism when someone uttered the "N" word or in this case "color" we think we should also copy their kind of sensitivities.

Add Comment



To prevent automated Bots from commentspamming, please enter the string you see in the image below in the appropriate input box. Your comment will only be submitted if the strings match. Please ensure that your browser supports and accepts cookies, or your comment cannot be verified correctly.
CAPTCHA

 
 

Archives

  • September 2011 (1)
  • July 2011 (4)
  • June 2011 (9)
  • May 2011 (25)
  • April 2011 (25)
  • March 2011 (30)
  • February 2011 (21)
  • January 2011 (24)
  • December 2010 (18)
  • November 2010 (25)
  • October 2010 (19)
  • September 2010 (8)
  • August 2010 (17)
  • July 2010 (17)
  • June 2010 (24)
  • Recent...
  • Older...

Categories

  • 2010 Guangzhou Asian Games (6)
  • Adamson Falcons (6)
  • Air 21 Express / Burger King Whoppers (60)
  • Alaska Aces (72)
  • Alvin Patrimonio (14)
  • Andy Mark Barroca (17)
  • Ang Sugarol: The Sports Betting Series (8)
  • Antonio Margarito (23)
  • Arwind Santos (23)
  • Ateneo Blue Eagles (36)
  • Azkals, the Philippine national men's football team (36)
  • B-MEG Derby Ace Llamados / Purefoods Tender Juicy Giants (127)
  • Babes (21)
  • Baller, the Official Lifestyle Magazine of the PBA (9)
  • Barako Bull Energy Boosters / Barako Energy Coffee Masters (29)
  • Barangay Ginebra Gin Kings (85)
  • Baseball (5)
  • Basketball (390)
  • Billiards (4)
  • Billy Ray Bates (4)
  • Bong Tan (3)
  • Boxing (143)
  • Brian Viloria (11)
  • Cecilio Pedro (1)
  • Chito Salud (16)
  • Chris Tiu (35)
  • CJ Giles (18)
  • Cyrus Baguio (15)
  • Danding Cojuangco (10)
  • Danny Ildefonso (7)
  • De La Salle Green Archers (15)
  • Dondon Hontiveros (15)
  • Dwight Howard (5)
  • Efren "Bata" Reyes (2)
  • Eric Altamirano (6)
  • FEU Tamaraws (16)
  • Floyd Mayweather (17)
  • Football (40)
  • Franz Pumaren (3)
  • From the Stands podcast (12)
  • Gabe Norwood (11)
  • Gerry Penalosa (5)
  • Graham Lim (1)
  • Housekeeping (28)
  • Jamal Sampson (12)
  • James Yap (72)
  • Japeth Aguilar (28)
  • Jay Washington (18)
  • Jayjay Helterbrand (21)
  • Jayvee Casio (9)
  • Jose Rizal University Heavy Bombers (2)
  • Joshua Clottey (11)
  • Jude Turcuato (14)
  • Kelly Williams (15)
  • Kerby Raymundo (18)
  • Kiefer Ravena (11)
  • Kobe Bryant (14)
  • LA Tenorio (17)
  • LeBron James (7)
  • Letran Knights (7)
  • Mac Cardona (15)
  • Major League Baseball (1)
  • Manny Pacquiao (115)
  • Mapua Cardinals (1)
  • Marc Pingris (11)
  • Marvin Sonsona (2)
  • Meralco Bolts (17)
  • Miguel Cotto (18)
  • Mikee Romero (4)
  • Mommy Dionisia Pacquiao (7)
  • National Basketball Association (56)
  • NBA Draft 2009 (1)
  • NBA Playoffs 2009 (16)
  • NCAA (20)
  • Nokia Pilipinas National Youth Basketball Team (5)
  • Noli Eala (32)
  • Nonito Donaire (25)
  • NU Bulldogs (5)
  • Patay ang Butiki web show (2)
  • PBA D-League (5)
  • PBL Primer (5)
  • Perpetual Help Altas (1)
  • Philippine Basketball Association (236)
  • Philippine Basketball League (13)
  • Philippine Olympic Committee (4)
  • Philippine Sports Commission (2)
  • Philippine sports media (102)
  • Poll of the week (2)
  • Powerade Team Pilipinas National Basketball Team (31)
  • Powerade Tigers / Coca-Cola Tigers (28)
  • Quinito Henson (40)
  • Rafe Bartholomew (46)
  • Rain or Shine Elastopainters (40)
  • Ricky Hatton (7)
  • Rodel Mayol (2)
  • Ronnie Nathanielsz (19)
  • Ryan "The Genius" Gregorio (58)
  • San Beda Red Lions (9)
  • San Miguel Beermen (83)
  • San Sebastian Stags (8)
  • Shane Mosley (20)
  • Shanelle Loraine (1)
  • Smart Gilas Pilipinas National Basketball Team (118)
  • Sol Mercado (25)
  • Solar Sports (13)
  • Sparring Sessions (8)
  • St. Benilde Blazers
  • Sta. Lucia Realtors (23)
  • Steve Nash (4)
  • Talk N Text Tropang Texters (73)
  • Tennis (3)
  • The Sweetest Tweets (3)
  • UAAP (49)
  • UAAP Cheerdance (6)
  • UE Red Warriors (13)
  • UP Fighting Maroons (19)
  • UST Growling Tigers (7)
  • Video (73)
  • Willie Miller (26)
  • World Women's 10-Ball Championship (1)
  • Wrestling (5)
  • Wynne Arboleda (17)
  • Yao Ming (1)
  • Z Gorres (4)

All categories

Advertisement

Links

Sports Guy's World
Yahoo! Sports
Deadspin
The Big Lead
Dan Shanoff
Sports Law Blog
Sports Biz with Darren Rovell

True Hoop
Ball Don't Lie
SLAM Online
NBA Fanhouse
The Basketball Jones
Hardwood Paroxysm
Basketbawful
X's and O's of Basketball
NBA Playbook
Free Darko
Sham Sports
Ridiculous Upside

The Ring
Max Boxing
East Side Boxing
The Sweet Science
The Queensbery Rules
Bad Left Hook

Frontline.PH Philippine News
Inquirer Sports
Philippine Star Sports
Manila Bulletin Sports
GMANews.TV Sports
ABS-CBN News Sports
Business Mirror Sports
The Manila Times
Manila Standard Today
Journal Online
The Daily Tribune
Malaya
The Philippine Online Chronicles Sportacular

Rafe Bartholomew
Toff Rada
Jude Turcuato
Mico Halili
Patricia Hizon
The Daily Smallville by Francis Ochoa
Da Jonas Blog
TJ Manotoc
Dennis Principe
Coach Ariel Vanguardia
Bleacher's Brew
Inside Sports
Inbound Pass
Gameface
University Belt
Chinoy Hoops Fan
Pasa Ball
HooPH
Basketball Exchange
Driball
Off the Bench V2.0
Filipino Boxing Journal
The Prawn Sandwich Brigade
underdogboxing
Pinoy Fight Scribe
From the Stands
Patay ang Butiki

Advertisement

Popular Discussions

  • Betting on Purefoods coach Ryan Gregorio (230)
  • So dude, what's up with the name? (152)
  • Rafe Bartholomew to new Pinoy soccer fans: No need to take cheap shots at basketball (108)
  • Thunder from Down Under: Scouting the Smart Gilas Australian opposition (85)
  • Rajko Toroman responds to Jamal Sampson (73)
  • The PBA’s three-conference format: Is it the answer? (60)
  • Krip Yuson replies (54)
  • Bullshit call by referee Maui Maurillo mars game 2 of Purefoods vs. Alaska (53)
  • Jolas and Jaemark (53)
  • Fire Quinito wins Best Sports Blog at the 2009 Philippine Blog Awards (50)
  • SBP executive director Noli Eala gets into a stupid Twitter exchange with a stupid blogger (50)
  • The wacky moves of Alaska (49)
  • Absolute Madness (47)
  • Air 21 leads the clusterfuck that was the 2010 PBA rookie draft (47)
  • Air 21 to send Baclao, Al-Hussaini, Guevarra to San Miguel, continues to ruin the PBA (46)

Recent Entries

From the Stands: The return of the comeback
Thursday, September 1 2011
A blast from Peyups past: My running diary of the UAAP opening day 2003
Thursday, July 7 2011
In the latest issue of UNO Magazine: The other Philippine football team
Wednesday, July 6 2011
Azkals coverage on InterAksyon
Monday, July 4 2011
From the Stands: PBA slowdown, college basketball on the rise
Saturday, July 2 2011
Azkals salvage draw against gritty Sri Lanka in World Cup qualifier
Wednesday, June 29 2011
Guess who’s broadcasting the Azkals’ World Cup qualifying match in Sri Lanka
Monday, June 27 2011
From the Stands: Gilas moving forward, and PBA Conference preview
Saturday, June 11 2011
Important announcement
Wednesday, June 8 2011
Smart Gilas places fourth in the 2011 FIBA-Asia Champions Cup
Monday, June 6 2011
From the Stands: A legacy of Alaska trades, and Smart Gilas rules
Saturday, June 4 2011
FIBA-Asia Champions Cup day 6: Casio, Douthit tow Smart Gilas to the semis
Saturday, June 4 2011
Dirk!
Friday, June 3 2011
FIBA-Asia Champions Cup day 5: Dondon Hontiveros shines against Jordan
Wednesday, June 1 2011
FIBA-Asia Champions Cup day 4: Mark Barroca saves the day for Smart Gilas
Tuesday, May 31 2011

Recent Comments

Snape's Advocate about Krip Yuson is a plagiarist AND a jackass
October 5 at 20:25
I'm with dotcom on this, so, b roski, these next few lines a' int for you, a'ight? Haha, all these bullshit comme [...]
KC about Smart Gilas places fourth in the 2011 FIBA-Asia Champions Cup
September 27 at 14:33
all comment are interesting. Y ou know guys since early 2010, i am watching every game Smar t Gilas (Pililpinas) los [...]
john about More on the Japeth Aguilar issue
September 25 at 23:44
"I really don't understand the reason why these businessmen who own teams in the PBA think that they are more impo [...]
GenoM about Guess who’s broadcasting the Azkals’ World Cup qualifying match in Sri Lanka
September 22 at 03:43
isn't this the guy that Ninoy pwned on live TV? LOL!
GenoM about Jolas and Jaemark
September 22 at 03:06
Jaemark, first of all I'm a bi g fan of your work here. your work has helped me through som e very boring business h [...]

Advertisement

Sports & Recreation - Top Blogs Philippines




Fire Quinito © 2009-2011 Jaemark Tordecilla. Images are copyrighted property of their respective owners unless otherwise specified.